Once upon a time (probably either a million years ago or a few months, depending on the day of the week) I was 17. It was Christmas break from my senior year of high school. I was super-hyper and super-boy-crazy. I was also exhausted from spending the month traveling from place to place in my awesome black veil of a madrigal dress singing for Christmas, and my friends and I were making a CD.
These are the 1999 madrigals. The dresses had yards of veil-like material. I'm on the right.
See, my friend Bobella* had a recording studio in her house and we were putting it to "good use." We recorded fabulous songs, we recorded conversations we had. It was pretty darn funny and if I could figure out how to attach an audio file to the blog I'd let you hear some... maybe... (but, as I said, and would have said if you'd have asked me at the time, my voice was tired from singing all month :) )
As for the boy-crazy thing I had a crush on this dude I know named Mhen Argletts*. He was cute, ultra-talented and totally un-obtainable. And for me, that meant that it was ON! (show high school-Sarah a boy who couldn't be gotten and I would show you my new obsession...)
Mhen was one of the many fun friends making the CD at Bobella's house. Of course he was - did I mention the ultra-talented? And so, when it came time to pick more songs to put on our CD I was put in a bit of a predicament...
Predicament being that only days before the CD making festival I had mentioned to Bobella that whenever I heard Linda Eder sing the song "Unusual Way" (from the musical "Nine") I thought of Mhen. My little 17 year old heart went pitter-patter at the lyrics, and I would belt the song out in my car whenever I was alone (did I mention I was overly-dramatic? Like substantially more than I am now? okay... moving on). Anyway, I told this to Bobella, and she told JON McBRIDE. And together they had given me this ultimatum:
Sing "Unusual Way" on the CD with Mhen Argletts accompanying on the piano OR ELSE they were going to tell him about my unusually dramatic and totally embarrassing crush on him.
Whey wouldn't do that to me... but sometimes they did things they thought were funny and this might be one of those things... I couldn't decide which one they would choose if I didn't follow-through with this song. On the other hand, I knew (and I mean KNEW) that if I were to sing this song in front of Mhen he would hear me sing and know everything. Know I was a crazy stalker-person (Fashion Blvd? Who lives on Fashion Blvd?). Know that our friendship for the last almost 2 years had been based on a lie because what I had based it on was plotting to get him to fall in love with me. And know what I feared above all else... that I was a total loser.
Sarah and Jon in "Oliver" 1998
And in the end, I sang that song. The recording is horrible, breathy and I refused to do a second-take, but it was sung. But that day a grudge was born. Born against Bobella and Jon McBride for making me bare my soul to someone who wasn't listening. Born against them for humiliating me. And born against them for being jerks. Luckily I didn't think Mhen learned anything from my singing it. My secret was safe.
That was until the next summer when Bobella and Jon would "casually" let a flow-chart of "who likes who" in the cast of "Music Man" fall into the wrong (read: Mhen's) hands with everyone's names in a clever code word except mine and his... *social death*
And so when I was sitting in a darkened theater next to my good friend Jon and the song "Unusual Way" came on, I punched him. and laughed. and then gave him dirty looks for the rest of the song.
Years later I would learn a lot of other interesting tid-bits about what happened the day we made the CD, and who was trying to save whom from not finding out about crushes. And even more years later (like this one) Jon gave me a Glee-related Christmas present which I have promised him makes up for the certain humiliation. Plus, I still get to be good friends with Mhen. And with Robella. And that makes me socially reborn.
So right now it looks like everyone could live happily ever after.

Sarah and Jon 2009. See? Still friends.





